Contact us

Understanding Orders for Specific Performance in Contract Law

In the world of contract law, remedies for breaches often come in the form of monetary damages. However, there are situations where financial compensation may not be adequate to address the harm caused. This is where an order for specific performance comes into play. Let’s explore what this legal remedy entails and when it can be used.

What is Specific Performance?

An order for specific performance is a court-issued directive that mandates a party to fulfill their contractual obligations rather than just paying damages for failing to do so. This remedy is particularly relevant when the subject matter of the contract is unique or holds particular value that cannot be easily quantified in monetary terms.

When is Specific Performance Used?

Specific performance is typically sought in situations where the goods or services involved in a contract are one-of-a-kind or irreplaceable. Here are some common scenarios:

1. Property Transactions: Land and property are considered unique because each parcel has distinct characteristics. If a seller refuses to transfer the title despite a valid contract, the buyer may seek specific performance to complete the sale.

2. Rare or Unique Items: Contracts involving rare artifacts, collectibles, artworks or custom-made goods might qualify for specific performance since finding an identical replacement could be impossible.

3. Limited Supply Situations: When goods are in short supply and not readily available elsewhere, specific performance might be necessary to ensure the contract’s terms are met.

Conditions for Granting Specific Performance

Courts will consider specific performance if the following conditions are met:

Inadequacy of Monetary Damages: The court must determine that no amount of money would sufficiently compensate the non-breaching party for their loss.
Clarity and Precision of Contract Terms: The contract must be sufficiently detailed to guide the court in enforcing its terms.

Feasibility of Enforcement: The court must be able to oversee and ensure the contract’s fulfillment without excessive difficulty.

Equitable Considerations: The party requesting specific performance must demonstrate fairness and good faith, having fulfilled their own contractual obligations or being ready and willing to do so or to quite the legal term, they must have clean hands.

Limitations and Exceptions

While specific performance can offer a powerful solution, it is not applicable in all cases. Courts are generally hesitant to enforce it for personal service contracts—such as employment agreements—because doing so may infringe on personal freedom and autonomy. Additionally, the specifics of the jurisdiction can influence the availability and application of this remedy.

Conclusion

An order for specific performance is a vital tool in contract law for ensuring justice in cases where monetary remedies fall short. It underscores the importance of honouring contractual commitments, especially when unique or irreplaceable items are at stake. If you find yourself facing a breach of contract situation where damages simply won’t suffice, why not contact us about the possibility of specific performance could be a prudent step forward.

This blog was prepared by Alexander JLO’s senior partner, Peter Johnson on the 15th January 2025 and is correct at the time of publication. With decades of experience in almost all areas of law Peter is happy to assist with any legal issue that you have. He is widely regarded as one of the capital’s leading business lawyers. His profile on the independent Review Solicitor website can be found Here